Skip to main content

Case Study: Mergers of banks

The past fifteen years have seen numerous mergers of banks in every part of the US. Invariably, bank managers point to significant cost reduction (increasing returns to scale) associated with consolidation of computer systems, combining neighbouring branch outlets and reduction of corporate overhead expenses as justification. Many of these mergers involved multibillion dollar banks, which appeared to be inconsistent with existing empirical research on bank costs that showed significant diseconomies of scale for banks with more than $25-50 million in deposits. Unfortunately, these studies used data only for banks with less than $1 billion in deposits. In a more recent study, Sherrill Shaffer and Edmond David used data for large banks ( those with $2.5 to $121 billion in deposits) and found increasing returns to scale (i.e., declining per unit costs) up to a bank size of $15 to $37 billion. Clearly, the owners and managers of the merged banks knew more about their actual cost functions than did the earlier economic analysts. The consistent pattern of mergers of banks much larger than $24 to $50 million in deposits was strong evidence that the existing research was incorrect.

Questions

1. How can mergers in the banking industry result in economies of scale (cost reduction)?

The mergers in the banking industry result in economies of scale (cost reduction) because of the Cost Efficiency. The most common rationale for Mergers and Acquisitions activity is believed to be increased cost efficiency. Many mergers have been motivated by a belief that a significant quantity of redundant operating costs can be eliminated through the consolidation of activities.

2. Do you think the same factors can lead to economies of scale in the banking sector in India?

Mergers can result in increased market power. Banks may buyout each other just to enter new geographic markets or to cut down competition. The recent example of this is the acquisition of UTI bank with Axis bank. Hence, the same factors can lead to economies of scale in the banking sector in India.

3. What are the other factors that can lead to economies of scale in the banking sector?

The other factors that can lead to economies of scale in the banking sector include:

Technical factors: These are often comprised of changing the product design and manufacturing so that average costs in the long run are minimized.
Organizational factors: As firms grow they can afford managerial staff such as a HR and financial department to develop ways of improving productivity and division of labor. These groups will become more efficient at keeping the books, (other tasks) than an normal worker would.
Market Power: As a business expands and becomes a bigger competitor in a the market it can lower its marketing costs by demanding discounts for products when bought in large quantities (bulk buying).
External Returns: This is when one firm benefits from lower average unit costs by taking advantage of the market industry growth.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Case Study: A perfect competition

In 1997, over $700 billion purchases were charged on credit cards, and this total is increasing at a rate of over 10 per cent a year. At first glance, the credit card market would seem to be a rather concentrated industry. Visa, MasterCard and American Express are the most familiar names, and over 60 per cent of all charges are made using one of these three cards. But on closer examination, the industry seems to exhibit most characteristics of perfect competition. Consider first the size and distribution of buyers and sellers. Although Visa, Mastercard and American Express are the choices of the majority of consumers, these cards do not originate from just three firms. In fact, there are over six thousand enterprises (primarily banks and credit unions) in the US that offer charge cards to over 90 million credit card holders. One person's Visa card may have been issued by his company's credit union in Los Angeles, while a next door neighbour may have acquired hers from a Miami …

What is the responsibility of business towards society? Why is social responsibility at a low pitch in India?

Responsibility of business towards society
A society consists of individuals, groups, organizations, families etc. They all are the members of the society. They interact with each other and are also dependent on each other in almost all activities. Thus, it has certain responsibilities towards society, which may be as follows:
to help the weaker and backward sections of the societyto preserve and promote social and cultural valuesto generate employmentto protect the environmentto conserve natural resources and wildlifeto promote sports and cultureto provide assistance in the field of developmental research on education, medical science, technology etc.
In other words, the responsibility of business towards society are:
Protection of environment.Better living conditions like housing, transport, canteen, crèches etc.Promotion of sports and culture.Opportunity for better career prospectsRegular supply of goods and servicesProper working conditions and welfare amenitiesGoods and services at…

Discuss the relationship between economics and management functions. How does the former contribute to the latter?

Economics and Management are ideal intellectual partners, each particularly fitted to strengthen and cross-fertilize the other. Economics provides the broader understanding of economic activity within which all organizations function; management in turn analyses the character and goals of that functioning. The management economics is often a subsection of the economic science and thus in broader sense a special form of the social, culture and Geisteswissenschaften. Like the economic science it is based in principle on the fact that most goods are limited and must by the participants be managed. It describes the economic functions of the enterprise within a national economy. In addition above all the optimal organization of the factors of production belongs apart from the company targets and the economical functions. In the broader sense also all households are enterprises.